this made my heart hurt

topic posted Fri, February 9, 2007 - 8:23 PM by  ColonelTCB
So I think we've all seen this sad xtc moment on youtube:
www.youtube.com/watch

You couldn't think there could be anything sadder until you saw this on youtube:
www.youtube.com/watch


Sorry, I should have warned you before you clicked that last link, you may become nauseous or suicidal or both.
posted by:
ColonelTCB
SF Bay Area
  • Re: this made my heart hurt

    Sat, February 10, 2007 - 3:21 PM
    Points to consider:

    That was more than three years ago. Since then some teenager has heard this cover version and taken away the message that XTC are "cool" and gone on listen to the real thing and has since become an XTC fan.

    Someone presumably brough this song to Moore to cover...but at least she showed the good taste to appreciate it, and tried to do a faithful version within the best of her ability. I'm not liking her band much, but the poor arrangement isn't her fault.

    Finally...one A. Partridge recieved a modest royalty check each time this cover version was played, and that is no bad thing.

    So all in all, perhaps a mournful sigh is called for here, but it's no reason for suicide.

Recent topics in "XTC"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Monstrance video Unsubscribed 0 February 26, 2007
Still in the Fridge Unsubscribed 1 February 14, 2007
"Well and Truly in the Fridge" RAB 2 February 10, 2007
outstanding line from an XTC song... Agent J 31 February 9, 2007
Happy Birthday Andy James 0 December 12, 2006